Cardcollector2 Sports Cards

Location: 

3455 Grove City Rd.

Grove City, OH 43123

Phone: 

614-991-0352

From the Store:

Cardcollector2 is a growing online marketplace for buying, selling, breaking and trading sports cards and collectibles

Pros:

Genuinely friendly, hobby-savvy staff: Shoppers consistently call out how approachable and patient the team is—great vibes for kids, newbies, and longtime collectors alike.

Deep, well-organized selection: Lots of singles, sealed product, and supplies on hand, with active buying/trading so the showcases don’t feel stale.

Online orders are buttoned-up: Fast shipping, careful packaging, and accurate listings show up again and again in buyer feedback.

Live-sale machine: Their Whatnot presence is big, well-run, and ships quickly—useful if you like the entertainment + ripping experience.

Community heartbeat: Regular events and a steady stream of shop traffic make it feel like a true local hub, not a dusty museum of cardboard.

Cons:

Live breaks can feel pricey: Some value-hunters on Reddit and elsewhere say certain Whatnot formats carry an “entertainment premium.” If you’re chasing comps, watch closely.

The Bottom Line:

If you want a welcoming shop with real inventory turnover and rock-solid online fulfillment, CardCollector2 delivers. In person, expect friendly help and plenty to browse. Online and live, expect smooth logistics and professional packing. If you’re extra price-sensitive, lean into in-store singles or their eBay listings—and comp live-stream buys in real time.